The verdict is the first state trial win against a major technology company over harm to young users. A judge is now weighing whether Meta must also change how its platforms work for minors.
A Santa Fe jury has ordered Meta Platforms, the parent company of Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, to pay $375 million after finding the company willfully violated New Mexico consumer protection law by misleading the public about the safety of its platforms and endangering children.
The verdict, returned March 24 after a six-week trial, imposed the maximum penalty of $5,000 for each of 75,000 violations of the state Unfair Practices Act, CNBC reported. The New Mexico Department of Justice called it the first state trial victory against a major technology company over harm to young users.
Attorney General Raúl Torrez said in a statement the verdict was “a historic victory for every child and family.” The state presented internal company documents and testimony from about 40 witnesses, including former Meta employees, educators, law enforcement officers and child safety specialists, Al Jazeera reported. Prosecutors argued that Meta’s design choices made it easier for predators to reach minors and exposed young users to content involving sexual exploitation, eating disorders and self-harm.
Meta rejected the state’s claims. “We respectfully disagree with the verdict and will appeal,” a company spokesperson told Reuters, adding that the company works to keep people safe, acknowledges the challenges of identifying and removing harmful content and bad actors, and stands by its record of protecting teens online.
The penalty does not require Meta to change its products. That question moved to a second phase: a bench trial before state District Judge Bryan Biedscheid on whether Meta’s platforms amount to a public nuisance and, if so, what remedies to order. Testimony ended May 21.
In filings submitted in June, the state asked the judge to order Meta to pay $953 million toward programs addressing harm to children and teens, the Santa Fe New Mexican reported. It also requested stronger age verification, limits on infinite scroll and autoplay for minors, blocked notifications during school and sleep hours, changes to recommendation systems, and a court-appointed child safety monitor, according to Source New Mexico. Meta argues the state is entitled to little or nothing and calls the proposals unworkable. None of those remedies has been ordered.
For parents and educators, the case matters because it targets platform design rather than individual posts. The recommendation systems, notifications and default settings involved shape how children use these apps everywhere. A 2023 advisory from the U.S. Surgeon General reported that adolescents who spend more than three hours a day on social media face double the risk of poor mental health outcomes, including symptoms of depression and anxiety, and said researchers cannot yet conclude that social media is sufficiently safe for young people.
Judge Biedscheid’s ruling on the public nuisance claim and remedies is pending, while Meta’s appeal of the jury verdict is expected to take much longer. Attorneys general in more than 40 states are pursuing related claims, The Associated Press reported. The outcome will help show whether the case changes how platforms are built for children or ends as a financial penalty alone.

